Sprinkles For Breakfast Baking Tips 5 Biggest Cookie Baking Mistakes

5 Biggest Cookie Baking Mistakes

I like to think of cookies as the gateway drug to being a baking badass (sorry for cursing grandpa). For some reason, it seems like everyone starts their baking journey with a batch of cookies. It could be anything from making homemade chocolate chip cookies with your mom as a kid to one night in college when you and your friends got really drunk and everyone thought you were a professional chef because you put peanut butter cups on the break and bake cookies. All it takes is one good batch of cookies, and you are hooked for life.

That being said, there are still a LOT of people who royally screwed up when it comes to baking cookies. And a lot of those people end up giving up on baking forever. But, I am here to tell you and anyone who has ever messed up a batch of cookies, it is not your fault.

Well, I guess technically it is. But I am here to help you fix that problem! Here are the top 5 Biggest Cookie Baking Mistakes And How To Avoid Them…


Have you ever heard the phrase “baking is a science”? It’s basically a fancy way of saying if you want your baked goods to turn out delicious, you need to follow the directions PRECISELY. Not basically, not kind of – but EXACTLY as they are given!


Get a kitchen scale. This makes it almost impossible for you to mess up your cookies with mis-measured ingredients.


I don’t know how to tell you this, but your oven is a BIG FAT LIAR. I know it is hard to believe, but it’s the truth and incorrect oven temperature is usually the biggest culprit when it comes to overcooked/undercooked cookies.


Get an oven thermometer. Unlike your super rude oven, this guy will not lie to you so you can bake your cookies at the correct temperature.


This is also your oven’s fault. Most ovens do not bake evenly, so cookies baked on the top rack will bake differently than cookies baked on the bottom rack.


Bake your cookies as close to the middle of the oven as possible – aka the middle rack. If you are too impatient to cook only one cookie sheet at a time, switch your cookies from the top to the bottom and vice versa halfway through baking.


And a lot of times, amateur bakers can end up with some pretty busted looking cookies. They may taste fine, but when it comes to food – we all know it is all about the presentation.


Get a cookie scooper. This will ensure all your cookies are the same size and shape when they come out of the oven! It will also help them bake evenly!


Woof. There is nothing more disappointing than a cookie with a burnt bottom.


I have a few suggestions for you. 1. Do not bake your cookies on the bottom rack (see number 3 above). 2. Get some new pans. Old/gross pans are a huge problem when it comes to burnt bottoms. I suggest this one. 3. Use a silicone baking mat or parchment paper.

Now get in the kitchen and become the baking badass you were always meant to be (again, sorry grandpa)!

I suggest making these Chocolate Chip or these Toffee Cookies.

Lindsay sprinkling her baked goods | Sprinkles For Breakfast

About Lindsay

I might be the only person in the history of the world that has ever been grounded from baking. That's right. When I was a teen, it wasn't the computer, or the


Similar Recipes

Oatmeal Chocolate Chip M&M Cookies

post 1

Make Your Own DIY Tube Pan  

post 1

How to Make Perfect French Macarons

post 1

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Follow us on Instagram

Holiday Season is here! And that means alllll the holiday baking! All my holiday recipes are on the blog! #goldenoreos #holidaycookies #holidaybaking ...

68 3

Those dumb knives!! I was so sick and just trying to find a place to tell you guys about my amazing new Pricing Calculator. It didn’t go well. But if you do want to see how cool the pricing calculator is, the link is in my bio. ...

46 1

She’s not like a regular spreadsheets. She’s a COOL spreadsheet. Also quick shout-out to Olive’s poop bag hanging out of the drawer in the back!

But The Ultimate Pricing Calculator is truly amazing because it includes our advanced pricing calculator that factors in your costs, labor, overhead and profit in order to give you a final price (but you don’t have to do any of the math!!) You never have to stress about pricing your goods and services again.

But that’s not all.

Here are some other things it does:
- makes pricing quick and easy for anyone who works with food
- specific ingredient section to cost out your recipes
- 100% customizable (gives you final prices based off your own costs and materials)
- all the formulas and formating are already done for you - you just have to input your data in a few cells
- includes a cost per unit calculator
- lessons to help you figure out how much you should charge per hour and how much profit you should make!

Right now you can get it for 50% off. Check the details with the link in my bio.

33 1

The Ultimate Pricing Calculator is actually designed to be the opposite of a “regular” spreadsheet. It is there to make things LESS stressful - becuase we have done all the hard (and boring) work for you.

It makes pricing quick and easy. All you have to do is input your info in a few cells and it automatically gives you the price you should charge for your goods and services.

It’s the best thing ever.

See how you can use it to price all the goods and services in your business in my bio!

60 5

Pricing was one of my biggest struggles in the beginning. I was always overthinking it and trying to analyze what other people were charging.

But with the Pricing Calculator, I no longer had to stress out about it. The calculator simply just told me what I needed to charge. It was AMAZING and a total game-changer.

And now I want to help make pricing easy for you too. Check the link in my bio to see how you can use the calculator in your business!

#smallbussinesssaturday #smallbusinesssaturday #cakebusiness #cakebaker

119 1

I’m so excited for you guys to try this! It’s such a game changer. See the details in the link in my bio! ...

93 13

It doesn’t matter if you are a baker, chef, content creator, or any other kind of artist.

If you are undercharging for your work, you are only hurting yourself.

Your time & money = wasted. And that sucks.

Becuase you are TALENTED. You should not just be....

-Bringing in a few bucks here and there.
-Breaking even.
-Or worse, losing money.

You deserve to be paid good $$ for your work!

But in order to actually grow your business, you have to have accurate prices.

And that’s exactly what The Ultimate Pricing Calculator helps you do. It is 100% customizable and tells you exactly what you should be charging for all your goods and services.

It makes pricing quick and easy.

You never have to stress about undercharging again.

Basically, it’s the best thing EVER.

Check the link in my bio for more details on how you can use it!

42 0

Time is one of our most valuable resources - especially if you run a business. Yet, so many people don’t charge for it when it comes to setting their prices.

I get it. Trying to figure out how much your time is worth is complicated.

There are a variety of factors that go into it - location, skill, demand, and more.

But we need to learn how to charge for it.

That’s why I dedicated an entire section to labor in The Ultimate Pricing Calculator. I make sure you add in your time so it is factored into the final price.

Then the calculator does all the magic math for you!

And becuase I know setting your hourly rate can be a little intimidating, I made a bonus video that helps you figure out exactly what it should be.

So tell me...how are you charging for your time right now? Do you think you should be charging more?

And if you want to use The Ultimate Pricing Calculator to help you set your prices, check the link in my bio for details!

#cakebaking #bakingbusiness #bakerylife #homebakery #pricing

106 2

The Ultimate Pricing Calculator is the best thing everrrr. It allows you to quickly price your goods and services with CONFIDENCE! And you don’t even have to do any math. (Becuase Steffen did it all for you).

Link in bio for how you can get your own Pricing Calculator!
#homebakers #bakingbusiness #cakebaker #bakerylife

584 15

Requiring a deposit is a simple way to protect yourself from all the 👻 out there.

They have already agreed to pay you. So in order to start the work, you should ask for some of the money up front.

How much?

It depends on if your prices are set up correctly.

When you have accurate prices, anything from 25-50% should work just fine.

But if your prices are too low (which is the case for MOST new bakers and content creators I work with), you are still not getting enough to make this worth your time (in case they still do 👻).

If you want to see if you are undercharging, my Pricing Calculator can help you check. It’s 100% customizable and will tell you exactly what you need to be charging for each item you sell.

Check out the link in my bio for more info!

80 2