Sprinkles For Breakfast Baking Tips The Ultimate Chocolate Chip Cookie Test

The Ultimate Chocolate Chip Cookie Test

How to Make the Best Chocolate Chip Cookie

So here in the United States, the Chocolate Chip Cookie is kind of a big deal. It is definitely the country’s favorite cookies, and by far the most common baked item made in people’s homes. But not all chocolate chip cookies are the same, right? Some are chewy, some are crispy and some are just mediocre. So what makes the BEST Chocolate Chip Cookie?

I spent an entire summer trying out different recipes until I found what I believe is the Perfect Chocolate Chip Cookie. This cookie is thick, chewy and has the slightest crisp on the outside edge. For the last couple of years, this has been my go to recipe.

But, more recently I decided that this wasn’t enough. In all my testing, I always focused on the cookie base – never the chips themselves. So I did a little experiment. I tested the difference between using Chocolate Chips, Chocolate Chunks, and Chocolate Shavings to see what ultimately made the Best Chocolate Chip Cookie EVER.

Learn To Make Quick and Easy Cookies

Baking Chocolate Chip Cookies at Home

The experiment was simple – I used my Perfect Chocolate Chip Cookie Recipe with three different forms of chocolate – Chunks, Chips and Shavings. Here is what I found.

Chips – The chips were my least favorite – at least the small Nestle Tollhouse one’s I used in this experiment. Even though these are the most commonly used chips in household baking, they just didn’t provide enough chocolate for me. They were too small. So if you are doing to use chips, I would suggest using the larger Ghirardelli chips (or a combination of both like the original recipe calls for)

Chunks – The chunks had a better chocolate to cookie ratio, and I love the crunch the chunks bring, but I still felt I needed more chocolate in some places. I found that the chunks were not evenly distributed throughout the batter. Maybe the answer is using more chunks – but in this case, I was still left thinking it could be better.

Shavings – The shavings were the clear winner in this test. Which I have to say, I was somewhat surprised about. I had never tried using shavings in my cookies before. After all, it is called a Chocolate Chip Cookie, not a Chocolate Shaving Cookie. But the shavings not only provided an wonderful chocolate to cookie ratio evenly throughout all of the cookies, but it also maintained that nice crunch from some of the larger chunks. The shavings did make the cookie itself a little darker, but I think that is a small price to pay for amazing flavor!

Homemade Ultimate Chocolate Chip Cookies

The Perfect Chocolate Chip Cookie - Full Recipe


No ratings yet


  • 2 cups flour + 2 tbs. flour
  • ½ tsp. baking soda
  • ½ tsp. salt
  • 1 cup brown sugar
  • ½ cup sugar
  • 12 tablespoons unsalted butter - melted and cooled to just warm
  • 1 egg + 1 egg yolk
  • 1 ½ tsp. vanilla extract
  • 2 cups chocolate chips/chunks, or 8oz. chocolate shavings.


  • Preheat the oven to 325 degrees and prepare a cookie sheet lined with parchment.
  • Combine flour, baking soda, and salt with a whisk and set aside.
  • In the bowl of an electric mixer fitted with the paddle attachment, on medium speed, beat melted butter and both sugars until well combined. the bowl of an electric mixer fitted with the paddle attachment, combine melted butter and both sugars (on medium speed) until well combined.
  • Reduce speed to low and add egg, egg yolk and vanilla. Beat until well mixed, about 1 minute.
  • Slowly add the dry ingredients and mix until just combined.
  • Stir in chocolate chips.
  • Roll ¼ cup of dough into a ball. Pull the ball in half and then rotate upwards 90-degrees so the craggy tops are facing upright. Join the halves together at the base to form back into a single ball (being very careful not to smooth the craggy top). See picture.
  • Place dough balls onto baking sheets 2 ½ inches apart.
  • Bake at 325 for 15-18 minutes, or until the edges are golden brown. The center of the cookies should look a little underdone.
  • Let cookies cool on the baking sheets.


*Makes about 24 cookies
Lindsay sprinkling her baked goods | Sprinkles For Breakfast

About Lindsay

I might be the only person in the history of the world that has ever been grounded from baking. That's right. When I was a teen, it wasn't the computer, or the


Similar Recipes

Oatmeal Chocolate Chip M&M Cookies

post 1

Make Your Own DIY Tube Pan  

post 1

How to Make Perfect French Macarons

post 1

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Recipe Rating

Follow us on Instagram

Our @sweetsindeed Edible Glitter is backkkk! ...

52 0

How have you stepped up your food photo game lately? #foodphotography #cookiephotography #foodphotos ...

114 1

It’s ok to be scared. But don’t give up. Keep going. Because once you get there, the results are even better than you imagined. ❤️ ...

112 1

The truth is you can get epic food photos with a phone or a dslr camera. You just have to know you to use it. That’s why I teach students how to use both inside my intro to food photo course Beyond Baking Bootcamp.

See how you can join our fall session with the link in my bio. ❤️

144 2

An epic food photos is the BEST marketing tool for your food business. Continuing to post mediocre photos of your amazing food is actually hurting you and keeping you stuck. It’s time to start upping your food photos and showing people how awesome your food is! See how you can do it with the link in my bio! #foodphotoclass #foodphotos #foodphotograph #foodphotographytips ...

302 11

If you are involved in ANY business involving food… mediocre photos are hurting your business potential.

So if you are a…

✔️Food Blogger/Influencer
✔️Home Baker
✔️Food Based Product Business
✔️ Restaurant or Bakery Owner
✔️Aspiring Food Photographer

Improving your food photos will *ALWAYS* help your business. Period.

➡️ And the truth is, you can easily upgrade your food photos right at home without any expensive equipment.

You can literally just use your phone. 📱

I have taught thousands of students how to do it inside my food photo courses. Are you ready to learn too?

✨ see how you can do it with the link in my bio!

102 1

Chatting with BBB VIP alumni @naturally.kelly about her experience inside the program!

And yes…I did have to get up and sign for a package in the middle of the live! Thanks Mr.UPS man!

45 2

Olive and Alexis 2.0 and here to welcome you to our fall BBB class! If you wanna learn how to improve your food photos, get noticed on social media and grow your business - see how you can join us with the link in my highlights! #foodphotographer #foodphotos #photoclass ...

69 4

Just found this old video and I cried laughing because…
1. I still wear 99.9% black
2. I still do handstands at home
3. I’m teaching free food photo classes this week!

So it felt appropriate to repost. And also…that video of me doing the “vault” is just too good not to share.

If you haven’t signed up for the live class, check out the link in my bio. May or may not break out a handstand during class. It’s going to be live. So anything is possible! 🙌

294 16

✨FREE FOOD PHOTO MASTERCLASS✨ In 1 hour, I will show you how you can take amazing food photos at home 🏠 without spending a ton of 💸. It’s time to up your food photo game! 💪 Sign up with the link in my bio! #foodphototips #foodphotographytips #foodphotos ...

210 10